High court may re-examine Civil Rights Act after LGBT ruling

Vin Testa waves a gay rights flag in front of the Supreme Court before a hearing about gay marriage in Washington in

Vin Testa waves a gay rights flag in front of the Supreme Court before a hearing about gay marriage in Washington in

AUS appeals court, for the first time ever, on Tuesday ruled that federal civil rights law protects lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender employees from discrimination in the workplace. They said that it would be wrong to stretch the meaning of "sex" in the statute to include sexual orientation.

And Davidson has speculated that, if the question goes to the Supreme Court, its ultimate resolution "will control other federal laws barring sex discrimination, including Title IX (which governs discrimination in federally-funded educational programs), the Fair Housing Act, the Equal Pay Act, section 1557 of the Affordable Care Act (which bars discrimination in health care and health care insurance), and the Equal Credit Opportunity Act". A lower court dismissed her suit, and a three-judge panel of the Seventh U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected her appeal.

"A policy that discriminates on the basis of sexual orientation does not affect every woman, or every man, but it is based on assumptions about the proper behavior for someone of a given sex", Wood wrote. "It would require considerable calisthenics to remove the "sex" from 'sexual orientation'".

The ruling came from a lawsuit brought on by Kimberly Hively, an in teacher who argued that the Ivy Tech Community College in South Bend had passed on hiring her because of her sexual orientation as a lesbian.

"Any discomfort, disapproval, or job decision based on the fact that the complainant - woman or man - dresses differently, speaks differently, or dates or marries a same-sex partner, is a reaction purely and simply based on sex", Chief Judge Diane Wood wrote for the court.

Syndergaard, Cabrera lead Mets past Braves 6-0 in opener
The game was rematch of last year's AL wild card playoff, won by Toronto 5-2 on an 11th-inning home run by Edwin Encarnacion. Syndergaard himself departed after six innings with a blister, as Kristie Ackert of the New York Daily News writes .

The ruling from the 7th US Circuit Court of Appeals in Chicago represents a major legal victory for the gay rights movement.

Lambda Legal, which handled Hively's lawsuit, said the school denied her a full-time job after she was seen kissing her then-girlfriend in the parking lot of the school.

In an opinion concurring with the majority, Judge Richard Posner wrote that changing norms call for a change in interpretation. Hively's case, Nevins said, will return to the U.S. District Court in the Northern District of in, which previously had sided with Ivy Tech and dismissed Hively's case with prejudice.

The ruling on Tuesday comes as gay rights advocates have voiced concern about the potential rollback of protections under President Trump. Eight out of the 11 judges were appointed by Republican presidents. The debate among attorneys on the case revolved around whether a court could expand the statutory meaning of "sex" to protect LGBT employees or if the word should only apply to distinguishing workers as "male or female".

When similar cases come before them, they'll have to account for findings of the 7th Circuit, which Nevins said is well-respected for the intellectual rigor of its judges and so has tremendous influence on other courts.

Recommended News

  • Death toll from Syria chemical attack rises to 75

    That was seen internationally as a major blow to US credibility and, for Obama's critics, a prime example of weak leadership. It pinned the "use of chemical and poisonous material" on rebel forces "to achieve their despicable goals and agendas".
    'Rick and Morty' may have revived McDonald's 1998 Szechuan McNugget sauce

    'Rick and Morty' may have revived McDonald's 1998 Szechuan McNugget sauce

    Just bring some back for everyone else, OK? Look out for Rick and Morty , Season 3 , Episode 2 coming to Adult Swim in 2017. The Rick And Morty Twitter account has stoked the fires of viewers' curiosity further.

    Low turnout will hand victory to Le Pen, rivals warn

    The final result of an election that is being watched closely around the world is still seen as highly unpredictable. Le Pen blames the European Union and its common currency for stifling the French economy.
  • Trump declares Syria chemical attack crossed 'many, many lines'

    Trump declares Syria chemical attack crossed 'many, many lines'

    Biochemical warfare against enemy militants and innocent civilians "cannot be tolerated", Trump said . Syria's government denied it carried out any chemical attack.

    Advertisers flee Bill O'Reilly's show but impact unclear

    Human Rights Commission spokesman Seth Hoy said he could not comment. Visit MarketWatch.com for more information on this news.
    New York's top court rejects Facebook search warrant challenge

    New York's top court rejects Facebook search warrant challenge

    Join the Network World communities on Facebook and LinkedIn to comment on topics that are top of mind. The court ruled against Facebook 5-1, saying state criminal procedures do not authorize its appeal.
  • UK woman who urinated on Trump golf course loses case

    UK woman who urinated on Trump golf course loses case

    The court heard she had been using a recognised right of way, and had been careful to observe Scotland's countryside access code. She said she was being treated for urinary incontinence and "needed urgently to go to the toilet" after jumping over a burn.
    United Nations  chief arrives in Baghdad for talks with Iraqi leaders

    United Nations chief arrives in Baghdad for talks with Iraqi leaders

    In the first 37 days of the Iraqi offensive to take western Mosul , 284 Iraqi troops were killed and more than 1,600 were wounded. Widespread displacement is one, with Iraqi authorities saying that more than 200,000 people have fled west Mosul since February.

    South Korean supporters of arrested ex-president to protest

    According to Seoul-based JoongAng Monthly Magazine she stays in the visiting area with him from nine to five every day. The former president was taken to a detention center in Euiwang, Gyeonggi Province soon after the warrant was issued.
  • Senator ends marathon speech against Gorsuch

    By "filing cloture" on Gorsuch's nomination on Tuesday night, McConnell automatically triggered a countdown to a cloture vote. The Senate's 52 Republicans can not overcome a filibuster of Gorsuch without the help of eight Democrats.
    Pepsi draws outrage for ad depicting Kendall Jenner at protest

    Pepsi draws outrage for ad depicting Kendall Jenner at protest

    Pepsi said in a statement that it was trying to promote unity, peace, and understanding. We are pulling the content and halting any further rollout.
    National Weather Service keeping an eye on areas for potential flash flooding

    National Weather Service keeping an eye on areas for potential flash flooding

    Much of the area is likely to see an inch or two of rain, with higher elevations possibly getting more than 2 inches, he said. Today: Today will be mostly cloudy with chances for rain showers and thunderstorms, especially in the afternoon.

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.